Electric Drums vs Acoustic Drums: A Detailed Comparison

By Melodics

April 8, 2024

Choosing between an electronic drum kit and an acoustic drum kit is a decision all beginners need to make when starting to learn the drums.

Drummers are presented with two distinct choices: the modern, technology-driven electronic drums set vs acoustic counterparts that rely on traditional sound production mechanics. Electronic drums, featuring pads with rubber, plastic, or mesh drumheads, produce sound from a sound module and have been prevalently available since the late 1990s, thanks to brands like Yamaha and Roland.

On the other hand, acoustic drums generate sound through the physical impact of drumsticks on a drum skin, offering a more traditional feel. Deciding between acoustic vs electric drums largely boils down to your personal preferences and specific requirements.

In this article, we compare the two types of drum kits, aiming to arm you with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision that resonates with your musical journey and lifestyle.

Pros and Cons of Acoustic Drums

Pros of Acoustic Drums:

Authentic Sound and Feel: Acoustic drums provide a genuine, classic sound with unfiltered resonance, showcasing nuances and natural imperfections that appeal to many drummers. The feedback from sticks on the kit and cymbals offers a satisfying experience, helping drummers learn the relationship between strike and sound.
Dynamic Range: They offer a full spectrum of volume and superior dynamics, allowing for more nuanced playing, from delicate wire brushes to full-bodied flams. Ghost notes and the dynamic range of notes are more precise compared to electronic drums.
Customization and Aesthetics: Acoustic drums offer a wide range of materials and customization options, enabling drummers to create their unique signature sound. They are also visually inspiring, motivating drummers to play more due to their appealing aesthetics.

Cons of Acoustic Drums:

Space and Volume Concerns: Acoustic drums take up more space and are significantly louder than electric drums, which can be problematic in shared living spaces or during quiet hours. Volume can be controlled using dampeners or adjusting drum heads' tension, but they are still loud without soundproofing.
Maintenance and Cost: They require regular maintenance, such as tuning and replacing drum heads and cymbals, which can be time-consuming and require more knowledge. Acoustic drums are more expensive than electronic drums due to higher production and material costs.
Transport and Setup: Acoustic drums are heavier and more challenging to transport compared to electronic drums. They require a larger area to set up and play, making them less suitable for small spaces.

Pros and Cons of Electric Drums

Pros of Electric Drums:

Volume Control: Electric drums shine with their volume control capabilities, allowing for quiet practice sessions using headphones or sound reduction mats, ensuring you don't disturb others. This feature is particularly beneficial in shared living spaces or late-night practice sessions.
Space Efficiency and Portability: They require significantly less space, typically around 2-3 square meters, and can be easily folded and stored away. Additionally, being mounted on one rack enhances their portability, making them ideal for drummers on the move.
Versatility and Maintenance: Electric drums come loaded with various pre-set 'kits', offering a wide range of sounds and customization options. They are also low maintenance, with durable rubber or mesh heads that don't require tuning, making them a cost-effective option in the long run.

Cons of Electric Drums:

Authenticity and Dynamics: Despite advancements in drum sampling technology, some drummers may find electric drums lacking the authentic feel and dynamic range of acoustic drums. This can impact performance and expression, as the tactile feedback and volume range of acoustic drums are hard to replicate.
Dependence on Technology: Electric drums need electricity to operate, which could be limiting for performances in outdoor venues or areas without easy access to power sources. Additionally, the sensitivity of pads and triggers may degrade over time, especially in cheaper models.
Learning Curve: Navigating through the multitude of features and settings available in the drum module can present a steep learning curve for some drummers. However, once mastered, these features offer enhanced recording capabilities and practice aids such as built-in metronomes and play-along tracks.

Sound Quality and Authenticity

When considering the sound quality and authenticity of electric drums vs acoustic drums, key differences emerge that could influence your choice:

Acoustic Drums:

Authentic Sound: They deliver a genuine, classic sound with unfiltered resonance, showcasing nuances and natural imperfections of playing, which many drummers find appealing.

Dynamic Range: Acoustic drums offer the entire spectrum of volume, from delicate wire brush strikes to full-bodied flams, allowing for more expressive performances.

Electric Drums:

Versatility in Sounds: Electric drums come with multiple pre-loaded 'kits' and sound options, offering a wide range of sounds at the touch of a button.

Sound Quality: Higher-priced electronic drum kits often feature more detailed samples and better sound quality, providing a closer approximation to an authentic drumming experience.

Challenges: However, they may lack the authentic feel and dynamic range of acoustic drums, which can impact a drummer's performance and expression. The limited volume range could also affect the overall sound of the music.

Innovations like the MPS-750X hybrid drum set attempt to bridge these gaps by combining elements of both acoustic and electronic drums, offering a compromise for those seeking the best of both worlds.

Practical Considerations: Volume Control and Space

When you're weighing electric drums vs acoustic drums, considering how they fit into your living and playing space is crucial. Here's a breakdown of key practical considerations:

Volume Control:

Acoustic Drums: Can be loud and may require soundproofing to avoid disturbing others, offering the full spectrum of volume from soft to very loud.
Electronic Drums: Allow for playing with headphones, significantly reducing noise issues and making them ideal for quiet practice sessions without disturbing others.

Space Requirement:

Acoustic Drums: Need a larger area for setup and play, which might not be suitable for those with limited space.
Electronic Drums: Though not significantly smaller in playing setup, they can be easily folded and stored, and being mounted on one rack makes them easier to move around.

Understanding these aspects can help you decide based on your specific needs and preferences. Whether you live in a small apartment or have plenty of space, your choice between acoustic and electronic drums should align with both your musical aspirations and practical living conditions.

Maintenance, Durability, and Cost

In the realm of electric drums vs acoustic drums, maintenance, durability, and cost play pivotal roles in a drummer's choice. Here's a closer look:

Maintenance & Durability:

Acoustic Drums: Require regular tuning and understanding of drum mechanics, adding to the maintenance time and knowledge required. Drum heads and cymbals need frequent replacement.
Electric Drums: Boast low maintenance with durable rubber or mesh heads that don't require tuning. However, electronic components may need occasional troubleshooting.

Cost Analysis:

Initially, electric drum kits were pricier, but have become more accessible since the early 2000s. Entry-level acoustic kits may be less expensive upfront, but acoustic drums incur higher production and material costs overall.

Electric drum kits vary widely in price, influenced by material quality, sound, sensitivity, and features like programmability and connectivity. Cheaper models may offer less durability and sensitivity over time.

For gigging, a decent electronic drum kit can be found around the $1500 mark. While there are cheaper sets, they may involve compromises in quality and features.

Learning the drums? Melodics makes it easy.

With a strong emphasis on an interactive experience that walks drummers through courses beat-by-beat and offers detailed feedback on their performances, we created Melodics to support drummers in learning via performance.

Over 180+ Tracks To Learn on Drums
Live Feedback On Your Performance
Beat-by-Beat Lessons for All Levels
Quick & Easy Set Up

Get Started For Free

The only software for drum lessons that keeps track of performance and kit advancement is Melodics. It's a very engaging drumming experience: just place their electronic drum kit on top of your acoustic drum set or activate the microphone on your device and begin to play. After that, Melodics will offer advice on song selection and technique, along with detailed criticism on how to get better.

FAQs

Q: Do electronic drum kits provide the same tactile experience as acoustic drum kits?A: Electronic drum kits do not replicate the exact tactile feel of acoustic drums. The rubber, plastic, or mesh pads on electronic kits differ from the sensation of striking a real drum head. Although modern electronic sets have come close, they can sometimes be more forgiving than acoustic drums in terms of playing technique.

Q: What are some common drawbacks of electronic drum kits?A: Electronic drum kits can have a few disadvantages, such as discrepancies between the force of your strike and the volume produced; this issue is less pronounced in higher-end models. Additionally, the physical feel of playing on an electronic kit can be unsatisfying, especially for those who are used to hitting the drums hard or are playing on a lower-end model.

Q: Do professional drummers incorporate electronic drums into their setups?A: Yes, electronic drum kits are widely used by both professional and amateur drummers. Professional drummers often opt for more expensive, high-quality electronic kits that offer better feel and sound.

Q: Is it more challenging to learn to play on electronic drums compared to acoustic drums?A: Learning to play on an electronic drum kit is neither easier nor harder than learning on an acoustic set. Beginners must still master the basics, such as drum rudiments, rhythm patterns, drum fills, and reading music, regardless of the type of drum kit they are using.

NEW LESSON DROP!

Come Together

As made famous by The Beatles

Learn to play this and over 500 songs in Melodics

Play this song now