The tools and resources a drummer uses can have a huge impact on thier drumming journey. For those looking for online drum lessons, you may be deciding between Melodics & Drumeo.
In this article, we’ll provide a detailed comparison of the main features of Melodics vs Drumeo to help you decide which platform suits you best. Clearly, we have skin in the game with this topic, but we at Melodics are passionate about helping students find the best approach to learning that suits their specific preferences. We know there are different strokes for different folks, and ultimately we want to see more drummers enjoying their time with the instrument. So, let’s find out which platform you should choose, or why a combination of the two is sometimes considered the best way to go!
Melodics offers an interactive experience which displays the notes and beats for you to follow, while the app ‘listens’ to your drumming. It then provides real-time feedback on your playing, so you know immediately how well you are performing, making it easier to correct mistakes on the fly.This hands-on approach is particularly beneficial for those who prefer learning by doing and want instant validation of their progress.
This interactive learning style means it is the closest you will get to a ‘tutor experience’ online. You will be informed of when you are off beat, rushing, or hitting the wrong drum. You can very easily track your progress over time, and be rewarded for your practice sessions. There are practice techniques, such as slow it down and looping hard sections that make learning easier. Finally, there is illustration style guidance on technique, hand placement and form throughout.
Drumeo, on the other hand, boasts an extensive library of video lessons taught by professional drummers. These high-quality videos cover a wide range of topics, from basic techniques to advanced drumming styles. While the experience is less interactive than Melodics, the depth and breadth of content provide a rich learning resource for those who learn best through detailed instruction.
The choice between video and interactive experiences largely depends on personal learning preferences. Melodics' interactive approach is great for learners who thrive on immediate feedback and want to dive into actively playing their kit sooner. In contrast, Drumeo’s video lessons are ideal for those who prefer to watch and learn from seasoned professionals, and don’t feel they need as much feedback on how they are playing themselves.
Melodics structures its courses in a way that adapts to the user’s skill level. The platform offers a progressive ‘Guided Path’, ensuring that students build a solid foundation before moving on to more complex concepts. The adaptability of the courses makes it suitable for both beginners and advanced drummers looking to refine their skills.
Drumeo also provides structured courses that cover a comprehensive range of drumming topics. These courses are designed to cater to drummers at all levels. Drumeo's volume of options means you can self-select your journey according to what you want to work on, and cover everything from fundamental skills to more advanced techniques.
Both platforms offer well-structured courses, but Melodics is likely better suited to a learner desiring a bit more guidance on the best learning path, that is personalised to where their experience level is at. Drumeo’s extensive content library is perfect for learners who want access to a broad spectrum of topics and techniques, but they would need to be comfortable doing a bit more searching and self-selection, which may suit a more advanced learner.
Melodics’ clear, guided experience is very beginner-friendly, preventing the feeling of “not knowing where to begin”. And with real-time feedback, beginners feel more comforted knowing how they are performing vs blindly playing along to a video.
The extensive song catalog also features beginner, intermediate & advanced versions of each song, so even if learners are not up to John Bonham’s level of drumming yet, they can still jam along to their favourite Led Zeppelin tracks. Finally, there is no requirement to read drum notation to start playing lessons with Melodics, which makes the early phases of learning a lot more accessible to all.
Drumeo also caters well to beginners with its structured courses and beginner-specific content. The extensive video library allows new drummers to explore various topics and find lessons that suit their learning pace. Their song playalongs require users to be able to read drum notation, and they provide great resources for learning this.
Both platforms are suitable for beginners, but Melodics’ likely has the edge in terms of providing a strong blueprint for learning that is catered for all levels, and versions of songs that beginners can enjoy. Drumeo’s comprehensive video library provides a wealth of resources for beginners looking to explore different aspects of drumming, but you likely need a base level understanding of drumming techniques to help navigate to the right lessons. Drumeo however has a ton of great beginner resources free on YouTube, including guidance on posture, ergonomics and form that is valuable for those starting out.
One of Melodics' standout features is its real-time feedback mechanism, which works on both e-kits and acoustic kits. As you play, the platform analyzes your performance and provides immediate feedback on your accuracy and timing. This instant feedback loop is invaluable for quickly identifying and correcting mistakes, helping you to improve faster.
While Drumeo primarily focuses on pre-recorded video lessons, it does offer some live feedback features. For instance, Drumeo Edge members can participate in live Q&A sessions with instructors and submit videos for review. This provides an opportunity for personalized feedback, although it is not as immediate as Melodics’ real-time analysis.
If immediate feedback is crucial for your learning process, Melodics has the edge. However, Drumeo’s opportunities for personalized feedback through video submissions and live sessions can also be very beneficial.
Melodics provides comprehensive progress tracking, allowing users to see their improvements over time. This feature helps in setting goals and staying motivated as you can visually track your journey from a novice to a skilled drummer.
[Tracking screen clip]
Drumeo also offers progress tracking features, including practice logs and progress reports. These tools help students stay organized and focused on their learning goals, ensuring a structured approach to improvement.
Both platforms excel in tracking progress, though Melodics' real-time feedback adds an extra layer of immediacy to the tracking process. Additionally, drummers don’t need to keep detailed logs of their progress as this automatically tracked in their Melodics account. Drumeo’s detailed reports and practice logs are ideal for those who prefer a more traditional approach to progress tracking.
Melodics leans towards a “learn by playing” methodology. The platform focuses on practical, hands-on learning, which helps students develop a natural feel for drumming through consistent practice and real-time feedback.
Drumeo incorporates a mix of sheet music and practical playing in its teaching methodology. Lessons often include notated exercises and examples, which can be beneficial for drummers looking to improve their music reading skills alongside their playing techniques.
Your choice here depends on your learning goals. If you prefer a practical, hands-on approach, Melodics is ideal. If you want to improve your ability to read sheet music while learning to play, Drumeo offers this.
Melodics boasts a team of professional drummers who have carefully crafted the lessons. This ensures that the content is not only engaging but also rooted in real-world drumming experience.
Drumeo’s instructors are some of the best in the industry. The platform features lessons from world-renowned drummers, providing students with insights and techniques from top professionals.
Both platforms offer high-quality instruction from professionals. Drumeo’s celebrity instructors might be a draw for those looking to learn from the best in the business, while Melodics’ practical approach is crafted by experienced drummers for effective learning.
The Melodics interface is one of the most slick and intuitive in the industry. To access it, you need to download the app onto your desktop or iPad, which only takes a few simple steps. Connecting your instrument should be seamless for even the least tech-savvy learners. For e-kits, by simply plugging in the device to your laptop/iPad, the software immediately detects the kit so users can begin playing immediately. For acoustic kits, there is an easy callibration step that involves hitting a few parts of the drum kit so the app can detect the particular parts.
The Drumeo app works in your web browser, so there is no need to download anything to your computer, or you can download their mobile app. There is no need to connect your device as the software is not set up to listen to your playing.
Both apps are designed to ensure even those who are not tech savvy can enjoy drum learning. Yet, there are a few more steps with Melodics to get your device connected. Both Melodics & Drumeo have excellent support teams who are on hand to help if drummers get stuck at any point.
Melodics has a vibrant Discord community where users can interact, share progress, and seek advice. This sense of community can be motivating and provides additional support for learners.
Drumeo also has a strong community presence, including forums and social media groups, which have large volumes of drummers participating.
Community support is strong on both platforms. Drumeo’s established forums provide a wealth of shared knowledge and experiences from a larger subset of users. The Melodics community is currently more intimate and built around more peer-to-peer connection.
Melodics offers various subscription plans, making it accessible to different budgets. The flexibility in pricing allows users to choose a plan that fits their needs and commitment level.
Melodics Plans:
Drumeo’s pricing is also tiered, with options ranging from monthly to annual subscriptions. The value offered through Drumeo’s extensive content library and additional features like live Q&A sessions makes it a solid investment for serious learners.
Melodics offers tiered packages to suit your budget and the specific features you value most in a drum learning platform, while Drumeo offers one plan which includes all product features. Melodics is the more affordable option.
When comparing Melodics vs Drumeo, the best choice depends on your personal learning style, goals and budget. We built Melodics for those looking for a more interactive experience with real-time feedback. While Drumeo provides a vast library of video lessons and resources perfect for those who prefer detailed instruction from top professionals. Both platforms offer structured courses, progress tracking, and vibrant communities to support your drumming journey.
A lot of new drummers enjoy experiencing both learning styles as they develop their skills. The combination of watching and imitating a professional drummer whilst enhancing your practice with feedback and structured lessons can sometimes be the perfect solution.
Evaluate your preferences in teaching methodology, feedback, and community engagement to make the best choice for your drumming education.
NEW LESSON DROP!
NEW LESSON DROP!
Come Together
As made famous by The Beatles
Learn to play this and over 500 songs in Melodics
Play this song now