Buy the Ableton Push if Ableton Live is already your DAW and you want a hardware surface for it. Buy Native Instruments Maschine if you want a self-contained beat-making instrument that works alongside whatever DAW you use. They look similar - a grid of pads, screens, encoders - but they're built on genuinely different ideas about how a track gets made. Below is what actually separates them.
This is one of the longest-running arguments in beat-making, and most of the answers online compare spec sheets. Specs aren't the deciding factor here. Workflow is.
The Push is a hardware control surface built by Ableton for Ableton Live. The current generation, Push 3, has been out since May 2023 and comes in two versions that share the same body.
Ableton Push 3 (Controller)
Ableton Push 3 (Standalone)
The 64-pad grid maps directly onto Live's Session View, so clips and scenes sit under your hands exactly where they sit on screen. If you already think in Live, the Push stops being a controller and starts being the instrument.
The pads are the standout. MPE means each pad responds to pressure and movement independently, which matters enormously for finger drumming and for playing melodic parts with any expression.
Maschine is a hardware-and-software system. The controller is one half; the Maschine software - now on version 3 - is the other, and it's a full production environment in its own right rather than a control layer for someone else's DAW.
Maschine MK3
Maschine Mikro MK3
Maschine+
Maschine's logic is patterns and scenes rather than a timeline. You build a pattern, build another, arrange them into scenes, and assemble a track from blocks. It's the groove-box lineage - MPC thinking, modernised - and it's noticeably faster than a DAW for getting from a sample to a finished loop.
Crucially, Maschine also runs as a plugin inside your DAW. You can build in Maschine and drop the result into Logic, Live, FL Studio or Pro Tools without leaving the ecosystem behind. The Maschine setup guide is worth a look if you're connecting one for the first time.
This is the part spec comparisons miss.
Push assumes you're making an Ableton Live project. Every control maps to something in Live. The reward for that is depth - nothing else controls Live this well - and the cost is that the hardware is close to meaningless if you leave Live behind.
Maschine assumes you're making a beat. It's built around loading a sample, chopping it across 16 pads, and playing it. The reward is speed from idea to loop, and portability between DAWs. The cost is that Maschine's arrangement tools have never been as strong as a proper DAW's, so most people finish elsewhere.
Neither is better. They're answers to different questions.
The Push has better pads. Maschine has a better pad layout for beat-making. Both statements are true at once.
Push's 64 MPE pads are the most expressive on the market - pressure, slide and per-note pitch bend give you nuance that 16 velocity pads simply can't. For playing melodic parts and for dynamic, expressive drumming, they win.
Maschine's 16 pads are larger, more spaced out, and laid out in the 4×4 grid that finger drummers have been using since the MPC. If your muscle memory is built on that grid - and most finger drummers' is - the Maschine feels immediately correct in a way a 64-pad grid doesn't.
If finger drumming is your main reason for buying, try both before you commit. The 4×4 layout is a stronger factor than raw pad quality for most players.
There's no getting around this one. A Maschine MK3 with a full software bundle costs roughly half a Push 3 Controller, and roughly a quarter of a Push 3 Standalone.
The Push also assumes you own Ableton Live. The Standalone version ships with Live Intro, which caps you at 16 tracks - pushing to Standard or Suite is a separate purchase on top of the hardware.
Maschine ships with Maschine 3 and Komplete Select, so the box you buy is a complete production system on day one.
If budget is the deciding factor, this isn't close.
Both ecosystems offer computer-free operation, and the honest answer for most people is no.
Ask yourself whether you will genuinely make music away from your desk. Not whether you'd like to - whether you will. If the answer is no, the Push 3 Controller gives you every feature except untethering, and you can upgrade later if you change your mind.
The Push 3 Standalone earns its price as a hub for a hardware or live setup, not as a sketchpad. The same logic applies to Maschine+.
Both of these are serious purchases, and neither is where most people should start. A cheaper pad controller teaches you the same skills:
Buy one of these, spend six months finding out how you actually work, then buy the expensive one knowing which ecosystem fits.
Here's the thing that decides how good your beats sound, and it isn't the controller. It's whether your hands can put a note exactly where you meant to put it.
Melodics is the practice app that teaches pad controller skills through interactive lessons that respond to how you actually play - real songs, real-time feedback on timing and accuracy, and a curriculum that builds finger drumming technique rather than just giving you exercises.
It works plug-and-play with both the Push and Maschine, along with 100+ other controllers - see the guide to connecting your pad controller if you're setting up for the first time. Lessons adjust to your level, so a first-timer starts with the basics while an experienced player goes straight to advanced finger drumming technique.
Neither is better in the abstract. The Push is better if you produce in Ableton Live, because nothing else controls Live as deeply. Maschine is better if you want a self-contained beat-making instrument that works with any DAW, and it costs considerably less.
Yes. Maschine runs as a VST, AU or AAX plugin inside Ableton Live, Logic, FL Studio and Pro Tools, and the controller can also be reconfigured as a generic MIDI controller through Native Instruments' Controller Editor.
Only in a limited way. The Push 3 Standalone runs Live internally so it doesn't need a laptop, but it is still running Ableton's software. The Controller version can send generic MIDI to other software, though you lose almost everything that makes it worth buying.
The Controller version is around $999, and the Standalone version is around $1,799, having come down from a $1,999 launch price. An official upgrade kit converts a Controller into a Standalone later.
The MK3 is typically around $489–499 and ships with the Maschine 3 software and a Komplete Select bundle. The smaller Maschine Mikro MK3 sits nearer $169–269.
Maschine's 4×4 grid of 16 large pads matches the layout most finger drummers have built their muscle memory on. The Push's 64 MPE pads are more expressive individually. For pure finger drumming, most players get on better with the Maschine layout.
Yes for the Controller version. The Standalone version includes Live Intro and runs it internally, but Intro caps you at 16 tracks, so a Standard or Suite licence is a separate cost if you need more.
Melodics is a desktop and mobile app that teaches you to play pad controllers, keyboards and drums. You connect your gear, play through lessons built on real music, and the app gives immediate feedback on your timing and accuracy - showing exactly where you're rushing, dragging or missing.
Melodics works with MIDI keyboards, pad controllers including the Push and Maschine ranges, and electronic and acoustic drum kits. Most major brands are recognised automatically, so setup is generally plug-and-play.
NEW LESSON DROP!
NEW LESSON DROP!
Doo Wop (That Thing)
As made famous by Lauryn Hill
Learn to play this and over 500 songs in Melodics
Play this song now